Review by Rosh on March 19, 2021.

In order to be outstanding amidst one's peers, they need not explicitly seek to be the most polarizing or unique of the bunch. Rather, having a distinct and clear vision, whether derivative of other bodies of work or not, and being able to execute it to its fully realized potential, is the deciding factor in what makes a work of art truly "good", in my opinion - uniqueness can often be a byproduct of this creative honesty. That's the best segue into a monolith of an early extreme metal classic like Celtic Frost's seminal debut EP/album I can think of, because, bar none, I take this to be the greatest piece of proto-black/death metal of the entire first wave movement, wielding a punishing atmosphere, an intriguing sense of esotericism, and sick fucking extreme metal riffs all as colors on a palette of unparalleled classiness. It's that classiness that makes this album feel entirely timeless and not even remotely dated to this day - and this is coming from someone who regards "Hell Awaits", "Seven Churches", and "Pleasure To Kill" as untouchable essentials of early extreme metal as well. Something about early Celtic Frost, though, feels darker and more solemn than the works of their boundary-pushing contemporaries, while retaining the overall crudeness, and it's not just because of abstract works of art like 'Danse Macabre' and 'Tears In A Prophet's Dream'.

The latter point is evident from the very beginning of 'Into the Crypts of Rays' wherein the band's riff structures and progressions present themselves as ever so slightly more involved and metallic than they were on the "Satanic Rites" demo released under the band's previous moniker, Hellhammer. This makes for a song that may superficially appear to be, but most certainly is anything but, a standard 80's extreme metal rager. The repetition of the chunky, bludgeoning riffs (which has influenced Obituary-type death metal bands to a larger extent than most second wave black metal bands excluding Darkthrone) met with Tom Warrior's proto-death growls makes for the most intense music yet conceived in 1984, and compositionally and tonally, still some of the most intense you can listen to. 'Visions of Mortality' and the now standard song which wasn't on the original EP 'Dethroned Emperor' are the perfect balance of crude thrash, doomy oppression, and mid-paced brooding. I cannot stress enough how well these songs embody driving, mid-paced, menacing aggression, counterbalancing the chug-heavy fare which serves as the marrow of the substantial caveman riffs with power chord crunches that do not offer any melody but do offer intriguing progressions which lend memorability and sullen catchiness to the music.

Basically, this is the template for crude, dark extreme metal riffs, neither fast nor slow, and it's the reason why bands like Obituary, Bolt Thrower, Morta Skuld, Asphyx, or Benediction are so successful at delivering mid-paced devastation. Speaking of such OSDM heroes, you can also hear the influence Celtic Frost's faster compositions on this album like the title track or 'Nocturnal Fear', as well as parts of 'Return to the Eve', had; the instruments charge forward relentlessly like a freight train, as songs like "Back to One" by Obituary, "Dying Remains" by Morta Skuld, and "Embers" by Bolt Thrower do in their intro sequences, and the vocals are like an additional spiked battering ram on the front of this freight train. Indeed, Celtic Frost can be pointed to for inspiring the tendency of later extreme bands to use their harsh vocals as an additional instrument (for example, with bands like Incantation, you get the sense that a lot of the atmosphere comes from those low, "cavernous vocals", just as much as the guitars), yet the above mentioned slower tracks still have a Sabbathy element of singing with the main riff. The latter point is important to note because it serves to strengthen the argument that with these dynamics, Celtic Frost deliver the blueprint for tastefully dark extreme metal - not going so far as to abandon traditional heavy metal, but still pushing the envelope considerably, both with their compositions and the atmosphere they evoke.

Lastly, I must admit my shortcomings in writing this review, and a shortcoming that I perceive most of my peers have when discussing bands like Celtic Frost. I, a tasteless, narrow-minded, and dumb metalhead view this album as an intense, loud, crude, badass extreme metal classic that I enjoy immensely on a sonic level. Yet it is so much more than metal, and I cannot stress this enough. Celtic Frost dealt in esotericism and abstract art and that is something anyone needs to understand before approaching their music as just another set of metal classics. I fail here because I do not have an appreciation for this esotericism that goes beyond acknowledging its presence and finding it fucking badass and unique. It's... hard to explain, but the point is I'm not well-versed enough on the influences (likely literature or occult mythology) these guys had outside of music to really grasp the transcendent art they offer on Morbid Tales, so I'll just keep banging my head to it.

Rating: 10 out of 10

Review by Felix on January 6, 2021.

How many texts have been written about Hellhammer / Celtic Frost? About the difficult youth of Tom G. Warrior, about his and Martin E. Ain’s far-reaching musical visions? Together with Bathory, early Sodom and naturally Venom, Hellhammer is still one of the most influential role-models for millions of extreme metal hordes. Celtic Frost soon left the path that Hellhammer had walked, but Morbid Tales (and Emperor’s Return) was not far away from the material on “Apocalyptic Raids”. It’s simple, non-orchestral and hardly progressive black metal in its most primordial form. It is part of the Swiss phenomenon that it changed its musical direction more or less consequently with every new release, but regardless of the musical quality of the different periods, it seems that their very early works were the most fascinating for the worldwide underground. I mention this, because the historical importance for the further evolution of extreme metal should not be ignored when writing a review. Even though I don’t think that Morbid Tales can compete with the gargantuan To Mega Therion, I must admit that its relevance is awe-inspiring.

The European version of Morbid Tales offered only six tracks, the US copies were supplemented by two songs (the title track and 'Emperor’s Return' – these cuts had been part of a compilation of Noise Records). Honestly speaking, the title track is really missing. I wish I could swap it with the non-musical horror scenario 'Danse Macabre'. However, the mini album features a handful of real songs and all of them have this idiosyncratic aura of defiance, resilience and negativity. 'Into the Crypts of Rays' kicks off the vinyl and its class lies in the eyes of the beholder. Is it just a simple, rapid neckbreaker with a dull solo after a short breather? Or is it the prototype of first wave black metal with a great chorus, minimalistic but surprisingly catchy, and with a subliminal form of magic that lives in every beginning? Make your choice, but be aware of the fact that its speedy design does not really represent the album. Roughly 50% of the material is characterized by the stoic, mid-paced flow of pretty primitive guitar lines, for example the well-known 'Procreation of the Wicked' and 'Return to the Eve', while 'Visions of Mortality' turns from a creeping monster into a high-speed bastard.

It’s difficult to understand the impact of Hellhammer’s and Frost’s early releases from today’s perspective, because they seem to have no unique selling point. Everything runs in well-trodden paths, but it was exactly the Swiss legend that made these paths walkable. The fundament of the songs was a necrotic tissue that had never shown up before in terms of extreme metal and this, the concise “Ugh” and the grinding, droning guitar gave and still give the music it's very special character. And to integrate a narrative part in 'Return to the Eve', performed by a woman with an absolutely emotionless pitch, showed that Tom and Martin (R.I.P.) had definitely already begun to think outside the box.

Finally, the anti-establishment-attitude of the group was also reflected by the production. It did not know any nuances, it was just a stew of death-affine tones. Anyway, the sound did not miss its effect. Having said this, Morbid Tales provided a very individual listening experience, both in terms of the musical content and the technical frame. The mainly speed-oriented 'Nocturnal Fear' closed the cycle.

Although I possess the first pressing, bought in 1984 or 1985, my copy has no poster and no lyric sheet. That’s not okay, because the cover indicated that a poster is included. Maybe I will file a suit against Noise Records for this impertinence one day… But the back cover was also not consistently truthful in its statements. The “thanx-list” promised: don’t panic, we’ll never wimp out – with an underlined “never”. Well… Cold Lake? 'Prototype'? But however, Morbid Tales does not deserve a review that ends with a bitter taste, because it was a grim, painfully resolute and widely excellent release of real outsiders from a comfortable region in Europe that crushed into an Anglo-Saxon and North American dominated scene. This was another interesting detail about this unit which seemed to be driven by its inner demons. Anyway, Hellhammer’s / Celtic Frost’s enormous reputation has many reasons, but one thing is for sure. We would not talk about them anymore if they had not been able to write great songs. You’ll find five of them on this mini album.

Rating: 8.4 out of 10

Review by Felix on June 9, 2019.

The Atomium stands in Brussels. It depicts iron atoms in the shape of the body-centered cubic unit cell of an iron crystal, magnified with the nearly insignificant factor of 165 billion. Enthroned also orginate from the Belgian capital. Compared with the impressive and unique landmark building, the black metal institution is slightly less known. But I think this state will change very soon, because albums like Sovereigns are predestined for pushing the band on the next level.

Generally speaking, this full-length can be considered as a typical work of Enthroned. It spreads the message of darkness while mixing brutality and viciousness. A few numbers of feeble sections, for example a totally lame and faceless part in the middle of the fourth track, are a tad annoying, but they remain exceptional and do by far not spoil the entire album. Its voodoo-esque intro appears pretty average, but already the siren-like leads of "Sine Qua Non", the first regular demolition ball, has these apocalyptic vibes that have made the black sub-genre so successful. The wailing leads of the fourth number are impressive as well, but, as mentioned before, a very strong, dense and powerful instrumental section leads to an intermezzo with almost dreamful guitars and strange, gnome-like vocals. However, already "Of Shrines and Sovereigns", the next track on the list, shows the real strengths of the Belgians: machine gun drums, expressive, sinister vocals, powering guitars. The spiritual background choirs during the mid-part add an occult touch. That's exactly the kind of Enthroned that I like.

Sovereigns does not glitter with an immaculate production, because its sound is a little bit dull. The guitars are vigorous but compared with some flawless productions of bands such as Marduk or Necrophobic, they do not achieve the maximum level of violence. Nevertheless, no fan of black metal will turn her or his back on this work. The technical side of Sovereigns meets more or less the international standards, although it cannot be described as perfect. And, as always, the songs themselves are of greater relevance and the exciting flow of "Divine Coagulation" shows that Enthroned still know how to forge a murderous blade of steel. They avoid experiments as well as an overdose of complexity. Moreover, they have closed their innovation department, but honestly said, I do not miss anything. Within the boundaries of the genre, Enthroned offer the whole spectrum from hailstorm to meditation - and I like it. The omnipresent blackness, the many vehement sections and the good compositional skills of the dark legion satisfy my needs completely.

Okay, maybe I was too optimistic concerning the question whether Enthroned are able to become more popular than the Atomium. But one thing is for sure: the Atomium consists mainly of nine atoms, but Sovereign is already the tenth full-length of Enthroned. Take that, Atomium!

Rating: 7.8 out of 10

Review by Felix on June 9, 2019.

The Atomium stands in Brussels. It depicts iron atoms in the shape of the body-centered cubic unit cell of an iron crystal, magnified with the nearly insignificant factor of 165 billion. Enthroned also orginate from the Belgian capital. Compared with the impressive and unique landmark building, the black metal institution is slightly less known. But I think this state will change very soon, because albums like Sovereigns are predestined for pushing the band on the next level.

Generally speaking, this full-length can be considered as a typical work of Enthroned. It spreads the message of darkness while mixing brutality and viciousness. A few numbers of feeble sections, for example a totally lame and faceless part in the middle of the fourth track, are a tad annoying, but they remain exceptional and do by far not spoil the entire album. Its voodoo-esque intro appears pretty average, but already the siren-like leads of "Sine Qua Non", the first regular demolition ball, has these apocalyptic vibes that have made the black sub-genre so successful. The wailing leads of the fourth number are impressive as well, but, as mentioned before, a very strong, dense and powerful instrumental section leads to an intermezzo with almost dreamful guitars and strange, gnome-like vocals. However, already "Of Shrines and Sovereigns", the next track on the list, shows the real strengths of the Belgians: machine gun drums, expressive, sinister vocals, powering guitars. The spiritual background choirs during the mid-part add an occult touch. That's exactly the kind of Enthroned that I like.

Sovereigns does not glitter with an immaculate production, because its sound is a little bit dull. The guitars are vigorous but compared with some flawless productions of bands such as Marduk or Necrophobic, they do not achieve the maximum level of violence. Nevertheless, no fan of black metal will turn her or his back on this work. The technical side of Sovereigns meets more or less the international standards, although it cannot be described as perfect. And, as always, the songs themselves are of greater relevance and the exciting flow of "Divine Coagulation" shows that Enthroned still know how to forge a murderous blade of steel. They avoid experiments as well as an overdose of complexity. Moreover, they have closed their innovation department, but honestly said, I do not miss anything. Within the boundaries of the genre, Enthroned offer the whole spectrum from hailstorm to meditation - and I like it. The omnipresent blackness, the many vehement sections and the good compositional skills of the dark legion satisfy my needs completely.

Okay, maybe I was too optimistic concerning the question whether Enthroned are able to become more popular than the Atomium. But one thing is for sure: the Atomium consists mainly of nine atoms, but Sovereign is already the tenth full-length of Enthroned. Take that, Atomium!

Rating: 7.8 out of 10

Review by Tomek on May 6, 2014.

More than twenty years building the scene, 10 great full lengths, live album, some EP's and few splits should be proof enough to anybody that Belgium's Enthroned are alive and well. Their newest album Sovereigns is going to be mentioned many times during 2014 and it will end up on many Year's Best, I’m sure of it. If any of you out there still don't know it, I recommend asking your neighbor for a slap in the face with his shovel for a wake up effect and then a quick purchase of the album because you'll need to listen to some good black metal while your face goes back to normal.

Here’s what you can expect. Album starts with an evil sounding intro and then all hell breaks loose. Enthroned attacks with a fury and sulphur to erase all non believers from their path with viciously blasting insanity. Sovereigns bursts with speed and intensity that remind me at moments of Marduk, just to move into soaring riffs that Satyricon accustomed us to, and then there are depressing passages that Forgotten Tombs creates. None of it obvious and all of it mixed with some wicked, malicious sounding intros and passages. Drumming moving with the speed of light and malevolent vocals are completing the picture of this blood thirsty monstrous beast.

Enthroned created album that raises the standards for smart and entertaining black metal. Superbly recorded, mixed and mastered they give us an album that is pure pleasure to listen to and dissect. I feel very affectionate about what they did here and I recommend that one to fans of well recorded and thought-out black metal. If forest recordings, Viking songs or such things are your thing - you must look elsewhere.

Rating: 9 out of 10

Review by Tomek on May 6, 2014.

More than twenty years building the scene, 10 great full lengths, live album, some EP's and few splits should be proof enough to anybody that Belgium's Enthroned are alive and well. Their newest album Sovereigns is going to be mentioned many times during 2014 and it will end up on many Year's Best, I’m sure of it. If any of you out there still don't know it, I recommend asking your neighbor for a slap in the face with his shovel for a wake up effect and then a quick purchase of the album because you'll need to listen to some good black metal while your face goes back to normal.

Here’s what you can expect. Album starts with an evil sounding intro and then all hell breaks loose. Enthroned attacks with a fury and sulphur to erase all non believers from their path with viciously blasting insanity. Sovereigns bursts with speed and intensity that remind me at moments of Marduk, just to move into soaring riffs that Satyricon accustomed us to, and then there are depressing passages that Forgotten Tombs creates. None of it obvious and all of it mixed with some wicked, malicious sounding intros and passages. Drumming moving with the speed of light and malevolent vocals are completing the picture of this blood thirsty monstrous beast.

Enthroned created album that raises the standards for smart and entertaining black metal. Superbly recorded, mixed and mastered they give us an album that is pure pleasure to listen to and dissect. I feel very affectionate about what they did here and I recommend that one to fans of well recorded and thought-out black metal. If forest recordings, Viking songs or such things are your thing - you must look elsewhere.

Rating: 9 out of 10

Review by Adam M on April 1, 2012.

Borknagar have returned for another Progressive and Folk laced release and a good one it is. There are numerous mood shifts that make this album constantly interesting at every corner. The combination of clean, melodic vocals with the occasional Black Metal rasp makes for an interesting concoction. At times, the band sounds like a pure Black Metal band and at others a more ballad driven atmospheric act. Regardless, the band sounds like they’re laying the foundation for ancient structures at almost every corner of this very strong effort.

The early portions of the release aren’t amazing, but a very strong start for the release in general. 'Frostrite' has more clean vocals than almost any song to be found and is one of the most memorable tracks as well. The release is littered with strong tracks though including a Metallica cover that is probably even superior to the original. In terms of innovation and depth, some of both can be found here. The band expands on the sound of their previous albums slightly, but really maintains what albums like personal favourite "Quintessence" great. The band is generally quite reliable and proves to be easily stronger than the related outfit Vintersorg on "Urd". In terms of musical performances, there is little to be faulted, but epic nature that they form together that is the most noteworthy aspect of this album.

Progressive, yet melodic, the album still doesn’t have quite as many stellar moments as something like "Axioma Ethica Odini" by Enslaved, but it’s only a small step below that. This album is very worthy to anyone that likes inventive and thoughtful music that is wrapped within a very structured framework. There anything overly complex on "Urd", but it is interesting enough to keep you constantly coming back for more.

Categorical Rating Breakdown

Musicianship: 9
Atmosphere: 9
Production: 9
Innovation: 8
Overall: 8.5

Rating: 8.7 out of 10

Review by Adam M on April 1, 2012.

Borknagar have returned for another Progressive and Folk laced release and a good one it is. There are numerous mood shifts that make this album constantly interesting at every corner. The combination of clean, melodic vocals with the occasional Black Metal rasp makes for an interesting concoction. At times, the band sounds like a pure Black Metal band and at others a more ballad driven atmospheric act. Regardless, the band sounds like they’re laying the foundation for ancient structures at almost every corner of this very strong effort.

The early portions of the release aren’t amazing, but a very strong start for the release in general. 'Frostrite' has more clean vocals than almost any song to be found and is one of the most memorable tracks as well. The release is littered with strong tracks though including a Metallica cover that is probably even superior to the original. In terms of innovation and depth, some of both can be found here. The band expands on the sound of their previous albums slightly, but really maintains what albums like personal favourite "Quintessence" great. The band is generally quite reliable and proves to be easily stronger than the related outfit Vintersorg on "Urd". In terms of musical performances, there is little to be faulted, but epic nature that they form together that is the most noteworthy aspect of this album.

Progressive, yet melodic, the album still doesn’t have quite as many stellar moments as something like "Axioma Ethica Odini" by Enslaved, but it’s only a small step below that. This album is very worthy to anyone that likes inventive and thoughtful music that is wrapped within a very structured framework. There anything overly complex on "Urd", but it is interesting enough to keep you constantly coming back for more.

Categorical Rating Breakdown

Musicianship: 9
Atmosphere: 9
Production: 9
Innovation: 8
Overall: 8.5

Rating: 8.7 out of 10